Rational Wine

A Life Through The Lens Of Wine

  • Home
  • New? Start Here
  • About Me
  • Philosophy
  • Words To Live By
  • Archives
  • Gallery
  • The Essentials
  • Rational Wine Note
  • The 7 Key Wine Concepts (FREE BOOK)
  • Wine Consultations

Rational Wine Review #15 – La Croix de l’Ermite Saint Joseph 2009

By Mark Law 4 Comments

La Croix de l'Ermite Saint Joseph 2009

Download Notes

Download Now!

I was in a position to get a mixed half-dozen case of imports recently for a very good price, so for the next few weeks we will be able to examine a very different range of wines. Old-world France seemed as good a place as any to kick things off, with this 100% Syrah from Northern Rhone as well. In my mind I was already forming some expectations based on theoretical knowledge.

The Stats

Take Your Own Notes!

Appearance
Clarity: Clear
Intensity: Deep
Colour: Ruby
Nose
Condition: Clean
Intensity: Medium+
Development: Developing
Palate
Sweetness: Dry
Acidity: Medium+
Tannin: Medium+
Alcohol: Medium
Body: Medium
Flavor Intensity: Medium-
Finish: Medium-
Conclusions
Quality: Acceptable
Readiness/Cellaring: Can drink now, potential to cellar
Identity: France / Rhone Valley – St Joseph / Syrah
Price: High-priced (~$45)

Notes

Long, slow tears
12.5% Alc
Aromas of stewed, dark berries, smoked meat, pepper
Flavours of stewed fruits, dark chocolate, sour cherries
Very fine tannins
Abrupt finish, but clean
Likely better as a food wine
Slow-cooked lamb

SkeletonDrinkWine

Has a basic structure, but lacks meat

Elaboration

First we check the label and make some observations – “La Croix de l’Ermite” literally translates to “The Cross of the Hermit”, but the following is more important –  Rhone. Syrah. 2009. With five to six years bottle age one could expect the fruit profile to be waning, but this wine was also sealed under screwcap, which is unusual for an import.

From what can be learned about the region and this varietal, I was expecting something warm-climate, juicy and higher alcohol. I didn’t look at this until after the first taste, and saw it was only at 12.5%, quite low for a Syrah-based wine. It could have been a cooler vintage in this instance, but without deeper research it one could not know for sure.

The nose was clean, but the palate seemed closed so I allowed the glass to breathe for a while, and found it became more pronounced after letting it breath for 30-60 minutes. Unfortunately it still lacked the richness I was expecting, as indicated by the lack of terms written about the flavour profile. With little incentive to go on, I resolved to preserve the remainder for another occasion.

As you can see, expectations and reality are not quite in alignment – this is the difference between theoretical and practical knowledge. There are no major faults, but no outstanding features, as though this was the scaffolding or skeleton of a wine – the alcohol and fruit character is there, but it lacks richness and depth. I would mark this as an entry-level French wine that may be best served with food.

Luckily I didn’t have to pay the full RRP of $45 in this instance, but perhaps this has more to do with the obscene taxes we have to pay on alcohol in Australia.

P.S. – I’m now offering personalised wine consults. If you want to expand your wine knowledge in 5 minutes, all you have to do is answer a few questions and click “submit”.

Read more: Rational Wine Review #1 – Reillys Old Bush Vine Grenache Shiraz 2009

Related Posts

  • The Rhône Valley in 1,000 Words Or LessThe Rhône Valley in 1,000 Words Or Less
  • Rational Wine Review #18 – Alain Jaume Réserve Grand Veneur Rosé 2012Rational Wine Review #18 – Alain Jaume Réserve Grand Veneur Rosé 2012
  • New Video: Red Wine GrapesNew Video: Red Wine Grapes
  • Review #52 – Les Pierres Blanches Vouvray Brut NVReview #52 – Les Pierres Blanches Vouvray Brut NV

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Reddit
  • More
  • Email
  • Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Telegram
  • Pinterest
  • Skype
  • Print

Related

May 13, 2014 Filed Under: Wine Reviews

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to Rational Wine and receive weekly reviews, articles, opinions and more!

Get My FREE Book

3D_7KWC_Reduced

Buy A Consultation

ConsultWineTemplate

Follow Rational Wine

  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Topics

  • Blog Announcements (21)
  • Day In The Life (35)
  • Impromptu Pairings (1)
  • The Essentials (8)
  • Thinking Sober (53)
  • Uncategorized (3)
  • Wine Experiments (5)
  • Wine Regions (9)
  • Wine Reviews (55)

Buy A Consultation

ConsultWineTemplate

Recent Posts

  • My experience of the Advanced Wine Assessment Course
  • Reflections on 2020
  • 2012 Campo Viejo Rioja Gran Reserva (or, How To Read A Wine Label)
  • New Video: Wine Vintages
  • New Video: Red Wine Grapes

Recent Comments

  • My experience of the Advanced Wine Assessment Course on Advanced Sommelier Exam – Second Attempt
  • Reflections on 2020 on Advanced Sommelier Exam – Second Attempt
  • Reflections on 2020 on Reflections on 2019
  • Reflections on 2020 on Will Sommeliers Go Out Of Fashion?
  • Reflections on 2020 on Hello, My Name Is Mark Law DipWSET

Copyright Rational Wine © 2013–2023 · Rational Wine · Consult Wine · The 7 Key Wine Concepts · Contact

 

Loading Comments...