Rational Wine

A Life Through The Lens Of Wine

  • Home
  • New? Start Here
  • About Me
  • Philosophy
  • Words To Live By
  • Archives
  • Gallery
  • The Essentials
  • Rational Wine Note
  • The 7 Key Wine Concepts (FREE BOOK)
  • Wine Consultations

How To Refine Your Tasting Technique

By Mark Law Leave a Comment

As my studies continue I find myself having to consciously refine my tasting technique.

On any topic it is very easy to speak in general terms. It acts as a safety net for your ego, so if later on you are found to be “wrong”, at least you are never “very wrong”.

This has become quite evident in recent times when it comes to wine.

The following are excerpts of wine reviews from one news website…

1/ …the wine is pale coloured, but powerful, and well removed in style from mainstream red drinking. The aroma’s earthy and savoury, with fungal and bitter cherry notes. These come through too on an elegantly structured palate with delicious, sweet and sour cherry-like flavours. The fruit sweetness quickly gives way to strong, savoury drying tannins.

2/ …The wine displays delicate grapefruit varietal flavours, pleasantly supported by spicy oak and the textural richness derived from barrel fermentation and maturation.

3/ …this wine reveals juicy, ripe and spicy fruit flavours layered with soft, easy-on-the gums tannin.

4/ …It’s a bright and fruity style, quite full, round and peachy, but not fat; and still with fresh, bright acidity.

If I were handed the above tasting notes, I would not be able to tell you what the wines are.

There is simply not enough information.

What would a normal consumer think?

1/ Would a normal consumer really be satisfied with a wine that tasted only of sour, bitter cherries, with earth (dirt? mud?) and fungus (mold? mushrooms? athlete’s foot?)?

2/ Grapefruit sounds nice. Is that all? What kind of spice? Red chilli peppers? Interesting, but not everyone’s cup of tea. What kind of texture? Creamy? Chalky?

3/ Spicy fruit flavours… What is this I don’t even…

4/ I’m told it’s fruity, but all you give me is peachy…

And yet these reviews come from an arguably mainstream source – The Sydney Morning Herald

Not Wrong. Not Helpful.

Having tasted wines of a similar style, I can tell you that I actually agree with what they have written.

If I had been handed a list of the wines, varietals and vintages instead, I may have written a similarly general tasting note.

They are not wrong. But they are not helpful.

It’s not my intention to single them out for criticism. Rather, I view this as evidence of a systemic problem in wine literature.

And because this kind of wine literature is so abundant, it influences how consumers think about wine.

I am likely to be guilty of this in the past as well. Put any two of my wine reviews together and they could possibly read the same, making it impossible to truly know a wine without looking at the label.

But we have to start somewhere.

Generalisations can be used as a key to unlock specific descriptors.

One technique I’ve learned in class is to use brackets, forcing me to look deeply for specific characters that can fall under a general umbrella. For example:

Black fruits (blackberry, mulberry)

Red fruits (raspberry, strawberry, maraschino cherry)

The aim is incremental and increasing precision.

Expand Your Palate

There will be times where a particular flavour or aroma becomes stuck on the tip of your tongue.

You know what it is, but you can’t put a name to it.

Go to your local grower’s market or supermarket. Have a stroll. Be aware.

Being general is easy but unhelpful.

Being specific takes effort. You will get things wrong occasionally. But you will learn much more.

Read more: 5 Reasons To Have Wine On A Date

Related Posts

  • Advanced Sommelier Exam – Second AttemptAdvanced Sommelier Exam – Second Attempt
  • Blind Tasting For The Wine NoviceBlind Tasting For The Wine Novice
  • Hello, My Name Is Mark Law DipWSETHello, My Name Is Mark Law DipWSET
  • How To Navigate A Wine Trade TastingHow To Navigate A Wine Trade Tasting

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • WhatsApp
  • Reddit
  • More
  • Email
  • Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Telegram
  • Pinterest
  • Skype
  • Print

Related

May 7, 2017 Filed Under: Thinking Sober

Subscribe via Email

Subscribe to Rational Wine and receive weekly reviews, articles, opinions and more!

Get My FREE Book

3D_7KWC_Reduced

Buy A Consultation

ConsultWineTemplate

Follow Rational Wine

  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

Topics

  • Blog Announcements (21)
  • Day In The Life (35)
  • Impromptu Pairings (1)
  • The Essentials (8)
  • Thinking Sober (53)
  • Uncategorized (3)
  • Wine Experiments (5)
  • Wine Regions (9)
  • Wine Reviews (55)

Buy A Consultation

ConsultWineTemplate

Recent Posts

  • My experience of the Advanced Wine Assessment Course
  • Reflections on 2020
  • 2012 Campo Viejo Rioja Gran Reserva (or, How To Read A Wine Label)
  • New Video: Wine Vintages
  • New Video: Red Wine Grapes

Recent Comments

  • My experience of the Advanced Wine Assessment Course on Advanced Sommelier Exam – Second Attempt
  • Reflections on 2020 on Advanced Sommelier Exam – Second Attempt
  • Reflections on 2020 on Reflections on 2019
  • Reflections on 2020 on Will Sommeliers Go Out Of Fashion?
  • Reflections on 2020 on Hello, My Name Is Mark Law DipWSET

Copyright Rational Wine © 2013–2023 · Rational Wine · Consult Wine · The 7 Key Wine Concepts · Contact

 

Loading Comments...